Best Overall
BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza Oven
Key details
- Presets
- 6
- Dimensions
- 20.31"D x 18.86"W x 10.44"H
- Pizza Size
- 14 inches
- Max Temperature
- 850 °F
Fourteen inches is where this one starts, and nothing else here comes close. Every other pick tops out at 12, and those two inches are the difference between a pizza that feeds one person and one you can put in the middle of the table. It's also the hottest oven in this set at 850°F, and the only one with PID control, which holds the temperature you chose instead of cycling around it. Big stone, high heat, steady heat — that's why it's the one we recommend first.
The six presets — Manual, Wood Fired, Frozen, New York, Thin Crispy, Deep Dish — are more useful than preset menus usually are, mostly because Manual hands the top and bottom elements to you separately. A Neapolitan wants a hard blast from below and a gentler top; a deep dish wants the reverse. Setting those independently at a temperature the oven actually maintains is what makes the fifth pizza as good as the first, and the stone lifts out in one piece when you're finished.
The trade-off is real estate: this wants microwave depth rather than toaster depth, so measure the run of counter you have in mind before you commit. The flip-up body helps, since folded the footprint is roughly half, and that's the difference between a permanent resident and something that goes back on the shelf between pizza nights. Once it's hot it stays hot, and it works through a queue of dough balls without much recovery time between pies.
The peel in the box is serviceable, though a second one makes back-to-back pies easier. And the capacity only pays off if you actually cook 14-inch pizzas; for two people sharing one pie at a time, a 12-inch oven here does the same job in less space.
Pros
- Fits 14-inch pizzas, the largest here
- 850°F with separate top and bottom heat
- PID control holds a steady set temperature
- Flip-up body roughly halves the footprint
Cons
- Largest counter footprint in this set
- Preheat runs past the stated 15 minutes
We think it's the best electric pizza oven in this guide for anyone cooking full-size pies: 14 inches of stone, 850°F, and top and bottom heat that stays where you set it.